The Best Way to Position Shares When Gifting to a Spouse: Learnings from Arctic Systems Case

Share This Post


Transferring shares to a spouse can be a strategic financial move, but it’s crucial to understand the tax implications and legal aspects involved. A landmark case, Jones v Garnett (Arctic Systems case), set a precedent for such scenarios, offering valuable insights into the best way to position shares when gifting them to a spouse. In this blog, we will delve into the facts of the Arctic Systems case and highlight key takeaways for effectively navigating share transfers within a spousal relationship.

Understanding the Arctic Systems Case

In the Arctic Systems case, the core issue was whether dividends paid to Mrs. Jones should be treated as income for Mr. Jones, given that he was the settlor of the settlement. The case revolved around several key questions:

  1. Was there a settlement?
  2. Was there any element of bounty?
  3. Was the Appellant a settlor?
  4. Was there any property comprised in the settlement?
  5. Was the dividend income paid to Mrs. Jones income arising under the settlement?
  6. Was the arrangement an outright gift?
  7. Did Parliament intend arrangements like these to be statutory settlements?

The case progressed through different levels of appeal, including the Special Commissioners, High Court, Court of Appeal, and finally, the House of Lords. Each stage provided distinct interpretations and conclusions regarding the taxation of shares transferred to a spouse.

Key Takeaways for Positioning Shares in Spousal Gifts

1. Understanding the Nature of the Transfer

The Arctic Systems case emphasized that the nature of the transfer matters significantly. In this case, Mrs. Jones’ shares were not a gift from her husband but were purchased directly by her. Understanding the nature of the transfer helps in determining the tax implications.

2. Outright Gift Exception

Shares transferred as an outright gift between spouses may be exempt from settlement rules. However, it’s crucial to meet the criteria of an outright gift, ensuring that the gifted property is wholly or substantially a right to income.

3. Documentation and Legal Structure

Clearly documenting and legally structuring the transfer is essential to establish the intention behind the transfer. A transparent legal framework can help establish the transfer as a genuine gift and minimize potential tax implications.

4. Influence on Income and Dividends

Consider the influence of the transfer on income and dividends. If the transfer significantly affects the distribution of dividends or income, it may be seen as a settlement and could have tax implications.

5. Consult with Tax Professionals

Consulting tax professionals or financial advisors with expertise in taxation and spousal transfers is vital. They can provide tailored advice, ensuring compliance with tax laws and optimizing the financial benefits of the transfer.


The Arctic Systems case provides essential insights into the taxation of shares when gifting to a spouse. Understanding the nuances of the transfer, documenting it appropriately, ensuring it qualifies as an outright gift, and seeking professional guidance are crucial steps in positioning shares effectively. By leveraging these learnings, individuals can navigate the tax landscape and make informed decisions when transferring shares to a spouse.

This blog is meant for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial or legal advice. The content provided here is based on general information and should not be used as a substitute for professional advice. Financial and legal matters are complex and can vary based on individual circumstances. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor or legal professional before making any decisions related to shares, taxation, or any financial transactions. Any actions taken based on the information provided in this blog are at your own risk. We disclaim all liability for any actions you take or fail to take based on any content in this blog.

Share This Post